Sumber: Lihat artikel asli di Wikipedia
| Tahun | Pemenang | Film | Peran |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1997 | Burt Reynolds | Boogie Nights | Jack Horner |
| Rupert Everett | My Best Friend's Wedding | George Downes | |
| Anthony Hopkins | Amistad | John Quincy Adams | |
| 1998 | Billy Bob Thornton | A Simple Plan | Jacob Mitchell |
| Ed Harris | The Truman Show | Christof | |
| Jason Patric | Your Friends & Neighbors | Cary | |
| 1999 | Haley Joel Osment | The Sixth Sense | Cole Sear |
| Wes Bentley | American Beauty | Ricky Fitts | |
| Michael Clarke Duncan | The Green Mile | John Coffey | |
| John Malkovich | Being John Malkovich | John Horatio Malkovich | |
| Christopher Plummer | The Insider | Mike Wallace | |
